Should I draft Ryan McDonagh or Scott Mayfield?

See our analysis of the choice to draft Ryan McDonagh or Scott Mayfield.

Register for free to get analysis using your league's scoring and roster settings!

Select Player to Draft

Please note dynasty rankings are based upon our 2023-2024 Preseason Projections and do not consider in-season performance.

Last Updated: Oct 4, 2023

Slight Recommendation

Ryan McDonagh

Change Player

Scott Mayfield

Change Player

TB · D

NYI · D

Injury Alert

Scott Mayfield · Ankle (DTD)

Skaters
2023-2024 Preseason Projections
Draft Value	0.41	0.36
ADP	Undrafted	Undrafted
OFF	14	17
B2B	10	10
PROJ	387.00	344.00
G	3	4
AST	22	17
PTS	25	21
PIM	22	66
SOG	90	113
HIT	67	101
BLK	164	148

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Draft Ryan McDonagh or Torey Krug Draft Ryan McDonagh or Jonas Brodin Draft Ryan McDonagh or Damon Severson Draft Ryan McDonagh or Anders Lee Draft Ryan McDonagh or Rasmus Sandin	Draft Scott Mayfield or Frank Vatrano Draft Scott Mayfield or Jake McCabe Draft Scott Mayfield or Colton Parayko Draft Scott Mayfield or Tom Wilson Draft Scott Mayfield or Cole Perfetti

Skaters
Season Statistics
PROJ	400.0	143.4
G	3	0
AST	29	5
PTS	32	5
PIM	31	35
SOG	90	36
HIT	33	54
BLK	139	105

Recent News
	Podcast: The Ryan McDonagh Domino Effect Published June 11th, 2024 via BVM Sports Lightning trade with Predators to bring veteran defenseman Ryan McDonagh back to Tampa Bay Published June 9th, 2024 via MSN Lightning trade with Predators to bring veteran defenseman Ryan McDonagh back to Tampa Bay Published June 4th, 2024 via MSN Predators' Free-Agent Targets to Replace Ryan McDonagh Published May 31st, 2024 via MSN Nashville Predators' Top Targets for New Top-Four Defenseman After Ryan McDonagh Trade Published May 29th, 2024 via BVM Sports Predators' Free-Agent Targets to Replace Ryan McDonagh Published May 29th, 2024 via The Hockey Writers Ryan McDonagh on TBL reunion \| Tampa Bay Lightning Published May 28th, 2024 via NHL.com Lightning trade with Predators to bring veteran defenseman Ryan McDonagh back to Tampa Bay Published May 24th, 2024 via MSN	Islanders' Scott Mayfield undergoes season-ending surgery Published June 24th, 2024 via MSN New York Islanders & Rangers Face Injury Challenges: Scott Mayfield vs. Jacob Trouba Published June 4th, 2024 via BVM Sports Islanders Handling Of Scott Mayfield's Ankle Versus The Rangers & Jacob Trouba Published June 4th, 2024 via The Hockey News Scott Mayfield proves more harmful than helpful to NY Islanders lineup in 2023-24 Published May 21st, 2024 via Eyes on Isles Scott Mayfield's 2023-24 Islanders Report Card Published May 16th, 2024 via Yardbarker Scott Mayfield 2023-24 Performance Report: Challenges, Expectations & Bounce Back Published May 16th, 2024 via BVM Sports Scott Mayfield's 2023-24 Islanders Report Card Published May 16th, 2024 via The Hockey Writers Islanders: Save Your Scott Mayfield Judgements For Next Season Published May 13th, 2024 via The Hockey News

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension