Should I draft Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy?

See our analysis of the choice to draft Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy.

Register for free to get analysis using your league's scoring and roster settings!

Change Players in Draft Analysis

Select Player to Draft

Please note dynasty rankings are based upon our 2024 Preseason Projections and do not consider in-season performance.

Last Updated: Jul 2, 2024

Strong Recommendation

Geno Smith

Change Player

J.J. McCarthy

Change Player

SEA · QB

MIN · QB

Passing
2024 Preseason Projections
Draft Value	0.89	2.51
ADP	152.05	146.44
PROJ	242.00	215.00
Comp	318	319
PAtt	498	505
PYard	3,748	3,411
PTD	23	20
Int	12	12
Rushing
Att	42	40
RuYard	197	182
RuTD	1	1

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Draft Geno Smith or Demarcus Robinson Draft Geno Smith or Jared Goff Draft Geno Smith or Bryce Young Draft Geno Smith or Kendrick Bourne Draft Geno Smith or Darnell Mooney	Draft J.J. McCarthy or Jahan Dotson Draft J.J. McCarthy or Bailey Zappe Draft J.J. McCarthy or Geno Smith Draft J.J. McCarthy or Ja'lynn Polk Draft J.J. McCarthy or Rondale Moore

Passing
Last Season Statistics
PROJ	227.1	0.0
Comp	323	0
PAtt	499	0
PYard	3,621	0
PTD	20	0
Int	9	0
Rushing
Att	37	0
RuYard	155	0
RuTD	1	0

Recent News
	Seahawks QB Geno Smith shares stat that shows how underrated he is Published July 1st, 2024 via Sporting News Seahawks News 7/1: Measuring Geno Smith's value compared to other quarterbacks Published July 1st, 2024 via Field Gulls Bang For Buck QB Index: Does Seattle Seahawks' Geno Smith Offer NFL's Best Value? Published June 30th, 2024 via Sports Illustrated Is Geno Smith the NFL's Best Value QB for Seattle Seahawks in Bang For Buck Index? Published June 30th, 2024 via BVM Sports NFL analyst's prediction for 2024 would put Seahawks' Geno Smith in an enviable position Published June 30th, 2024 via AtoZ Sports NFC Notes: Geno Smith, Sam Howell, Leonard Floyd, 49ers, Cardinals, Seahawks - Published June 30th, 2024 via NFL Trade Rumors Geno Smith earns high praise from Panthers head coach Dave Canales Published June 29th, 2024 via Sporting News Seattle Seahawks' most underrated player: QB Geno Smith Published June 29th, 2024 via MSN	Adam Thielen gets real on Vikings QB JJ McCarthy's accuracy after surprising workout Published July 2nd, 2024 via ClutchPoints Minnesota Vikings Teammate Praises Rookie QB J.J. McCarthy Published July 2nd, 2024 via Yardbarker The J.J. McCarthy Hype Train Continues to Choo Choo Published July 2nd, 2024 via VikingsTerritory.com Former Vikings Star Gets Honest About J.J. McCarthy After Training Session Published July 2nd, 2024 via Heavy.com Panthers WR discusses workout with Vikings' J.J. McCarthy Published July 2nd, 2024 via Yardbarker Vikings fans really shouldn't be surprised by JJ McCarthy's early struggles Published July 2nd, 2024 via FanSided Vikings add former J.J. McCarthy teammate in latest ESPN 2025 mock draft Published July 2nd, 2024 via The Viking Age Familiar Word Returns for Vikings' J.J. McCarthy Plan Published July 2nd, 2024 via VikingsTerritory.com

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension