Should I draft J.D. Davis or Jake McCarthy?

See our analysis of the choice to draft J.D. Davis or Jake McCarthy.

PLEASE NOTE this is a draft choice comparison analysis based upon Preseason Projections only. As the baseball season is already underway, you may instead prefer to view our breakdown of a trade for these players which is based upon several more factors including in-season performance.

Change Players in Draft Analysis

Select Player to Draft

Strong Recommendation

J.D. Davis

Change Player

Jake McCarthy

Change Player

NYY · 3B,1B

ARI · RF,LF

Batting
2024 Preseason Projections
Draft Value	-0.13	-0.02
ADP	Undrafted	Undrafted
PROJ	101.00	141.00
AB	245	272
R	31	36
H	57	68
2B	11	11
3B	0	4
HR	8	4
RBI	32	24
SB	0	20
K	81	62
BB	27	24
AVG	.233	.250
OBP	.315	.312
SLG	.376	.364
OPS	.691	.676

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Draft J.D. Davis or Joey Wendle Draft J.D. Davis or Mike Tauchman Draft J.D. Davis or Abraham Toro Draft J.D. Davis or Kyle Manzardo Draft J.D. Davis or Dominic Canzone	Draft Jake McCarthy or Jason Heyward Draft Jake McCarthy or Nick Gordon Draft Jake McCarthy or Jonathan Aranda Draft Jake McCarthy or Stone Garrett Draft Jake McCarthy or Ramon Urias

Batting
Season Statistics
PROJ	42.0	114.0
AB	132	188
R	13	27
H	30	53
2B	5	7
3B	0	2
HR	4	3
RBI	6	19
SB	0	12
K	35	38
BB	11	21
AVG	.227	.282
OBP	.301	.369
SLG	.356	.388
OPS	.657	.757

Recent News
	Yankees' J.D. Davis: Late scratch Sunday Published June 30th, 2024 via CBS Sports Yankees acquire J.D. Davis in trade with Athletics Published June 29th, 2024 via MSN J.D. Davis' RBI double \| 06/28/2024 \| New York Yankees Published June 28th, 2024 via MLB.com J.D. Davis costing Yankees prorated share of minimum, with Oakland paying New York $927,000 Published June 27th, 2024 via MSN Yankees acquire J.D. Davis from Athletics for Jordan Groshans Published June 27th, 2024 via MSN Yankees' J.D. Davis plans on mashing again after nonstop drama in difficult first half Published June 27th, 2024 via MSN Mets pivoting from J.D. Davis to J.D. Martinez ended up saving season Published June 26th, 2024 via New York Post J.D. Davis Acquired By Yankees Published June 26th, 2024 via MSN	Diamondbacks' Jake McCarthy: Sitting against lefty Published June 28th, 2024 via CBS Sports Jake McCarthy Tallies Three Hits, Swipes Two Bags In Thursday’s Victory Published June 20th, 2024 Diamondbacks' Jake McCarthy: Swipes two, scores two Published June 20th, 2024 via CBS Sports Video: Jake McCarthy - Arizona Diamondbacks' agent of chaos #mlb #arizonadiamondbacks Published June 20th, 2024 via Arizona Sports Diamondbacks' Jake McCarthy: Out against left-hander Published June 19th, 2024 via CBS Sports Jake McCarthy's 2-run homer helps carry the Diamondbacks to a 9-3 win against the Padres Published June 18th, 2024 via Yahoo Canada Sports Steals give McCarthy fantasy upside sans Carroll Published June 17th, 2024 via NBC Sports Why Jake McCarthy is again emerging as a key piece for the Diamondbacks Published June 17th, 2024 via The Arizona Republic

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension