Should I trade David Bednar for Clay Holmes?

See our analysis of a proposed trade of David Bednar for Clay Holmes.

Register for free to get analysis using your league's scoring and roster settings!

Change Players in Trade Analysis

Select Player(s) to Trade Away

Select Player(s) to Trade For

Recommended

David Bednar

Change Player

Clay Holmes

Change Player

PIT · RP

NYY · RP

Injury Alert

David Bednar · Oblique (Day To Day)

Pitching
Rest of Season Projections
Trade Value	0.54	0.80
FPTS	108.00	135.00
W	2	1
L	2	2
SV	14	18
IP	22.2	27.1
H	21	33
ER	13	11
K	24	31
BB	5	7
ERA	5.31	3.68
WHIP	1.16	1.50

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Trade David Bednar for Hector Neris Trade David Bednar for Jordan Hicks Trade David Bednar for Pedro Avila Trade David Bednar for Justin Martinez Trade David Bednar for Colin Holderman	Trade Clay Holmes for Yimi Garcia Trade Clay Holmes for Evan Phillips Trade Clay Holmes for Robert Suarez Trade Clay Holmes for Kyle Finnegan Trade Clay Holmes for Peter Fairbanks

Pitching
Season Statistics
FPTS	131.0	146.0
W	3	1
L	3	3
SV	16	19
IP	31.1	34.0
H	28	37
ER	18	10
K	32	34
BB	7	8
ERA	5.21	2.65
WHIP	1.13	1.32

Recent News
	Pirates' David Bednar: Progressing, but timeline unknown Published June 30th, 2024 via CBS Sports Bucs Arghticles: Pirates place David Bednar on IL Published June 25th, 2024 via Bucs Dugout David Bednar Placed On Injured List Sunday Published June 23rd, 2024 via MSN With David Bednar on injured list, Pirates bullpen gets new look Published June 23rd, 2024 via TribLIVE Aroldis Chapman Steps Up as Pirates Place All-Star Closer David Bednar on Injured List Published June 23rd, 2024 via BVM Sports How Pirates Plan to Handle Closer Role in David Bednar's Absence Published June 23rd, 2024 via Pittsburgh Baseball Now Pirates Closer David Bednar Placed on IL with Left Oblique Strain Published June 23rd, 2024 via BVM Sports David Bednar Placed On Injured List Sunday Published June 23rd, 2024	How Yankees closer Clay Holmes ended up with his new 'subtle' entrance Published June 29th, 2024 via MSN Yankees' Clay Holmes calls out culprit in brutal loss to Mariners Published June 29th, 2024 via MSN Clay Holmes is becoming one of the Yankees' biggest difference-makers Published June 28th, 2024 via MSN Morash: Clay Holmes 'absolutely an issue' for Yankees Published June 20th, 2024 via MSN Clay Holmes, Yankees react to closer's sudden slump Published June 20th, 2024 via MSN Bullpen report: Dedniel Núñez rising, concerns for Clay Holmes and more Published June 20th, 2024 via The New York Times Clay Holmes' Sudden Slump Begins To Bite Yankees Hard Published June 20th, 2024 via Pinstripes Nation Clay Holmes, Yankees react to closer's sudden slump Published June 20th, 2024 via NJ.com

Rest of Season Schedule
Tue Jul 2	vs. STL Pitcher: Gibson	vs. CIN Pitcher: Ashcraft
Wed Jul 3	vs. STL Pitcher: Mikolas	vs. CIN Pitcher: Abbott
Thu Jul 4	vs. STL Pitcher: Pallante	vs. CIN Pitcher: Montas
Fri Jul 5	vs. NYM Pitcher: Severino	vs. BOS Pitcher: Houck
Sat Jul 6	vs. NYM Pitcher: Peterson	vs. BOS Pitcher: Winckowski
Sun Jul 7	vs. NYM Pitcher: Manaea	vs. BOS Pitcher: Crawford
Mon Jul 8	vs. NYM Pitcher: Quintana
Tue Jul 9	@ MIL Pitcher: Rea	@ TB Pitcher: Pepiot
Wed Jul 10	@ MIL Pitcher: Myers	@ TB Pitcher: Eflin
Thu Jul 11	@ MIL Pitcher: Peralta	@ TB Pitcher: Civale
Fri Jul 12	@ CHW Pitcher: Crochet	@ BAL Pitcher: Suarez
Sat Jul 13	@ CHW Pitcher: Flexen	@ BAL Pitcher: Povich
Sun Jul 14	@ CHW Pitcher: Clevinger	@ BAL Pitcher: Irvin
Fri Jul 19	vs. PHI	vs. TB
Sat Jul 20	vs. PHI	vs. TB
Sun Jul 21	vs. PHI	vs. TB
Mon Jul 22	vs. STL	vs. TB
Tue Jul 23	vs. STL	vs. NYM
Wed Jul 24	vs. STL	vs. NYM
Fri Jul 26	@ ARI	@ BOS
Sat Jul 27	@ ARI	@ BOS
Sun Jul 28	@ ARI	@ BOS
Mon Jul 29	@ HOU	@ PHI
Tue Jul 30	@ HOU	@ PHI
Wed Jul 31	@ HOU	@ PHI
Fri Aug 2	vs. ARI	vs. TOR
Sat Aug 3	vs. ARI	vs. TOR
Sun Aug 4	vs. ARI	vs. TOR
Tue Aug 6	vs. SD	vs. LAA
Wed Aug 7	vs. SD	vs. LAA
Thu Aug 8	vs. SD	vs. LAA
Fri Aug 9	@ LAD	vs. TEX
Sat Aug 10	@ LAD	vs. TEX
Sun Aug 11	@ LAD	vs. TEX
Mon Aug 12	@ SD	@ CHW
Tue Aug 13	@ SD	@ CHW
Wed Aug 14	@ SD	@ CHW
Fri Aug 16	vs. SEA	@ DET
Sat Aug 17	vs. SEA	@ DET
Sun Aug 18	vs. SEA	@ DET
Mon Aug 19	@ TEX
Tue Aug 20	@ TEX	vs. CLE
Wed Aug 21	@ TEX	vs. CLE
Thu Aug 22	vs. CIN	vs. CLE
Fri Aug 23	vs. CIN	vs. COL
Sat Aug 24	vs. CIN	vs. COL
Sun Aug 25	vs. CIN	vs. COL
Mon Aug 26	vs. CHC	@ WSH
Tue Aug 27	vs. CHC	@ WSH
Wed Aug 28	vs. CHC	@ WSH
Fri Aug 30	@ CLE	vs. STL
Sat Aug 31	@ CLE	vs. STL
Sun Sep 1	@ CLE	vs. STL
Mon Sep 2	@ CHC	@ TEX
Tue Sep 3	@ CHC	@ TEX
Wed Sep 4	@ CHC	@ TEX
Thu Sep 5	vs. WSH
Fri Sep 6	vs. WSH	@ CHC
Sat Sep 7	vs. WSH	@ CHC
Sun Sep 8	vs. WSH	@ CHC
Mon Sep 9	vs. MIA	vs. KC
Tue Sep 10	vs. MIA	vs. KC
Wed Sep 11	vs. MIA	vs. KC
Thu Sep 12		vs. BOS
Fri Sep 13	vs. KC	vs. BOS
Sat Sep 14	vs. KC	vs. BOS
Sun Sep 15	vs. KC	vs. BOS
Mon Sep 16	@ STL
Tue Sep 17	@ STL	@ SEA
Wed Sep 18	@ STL	@ SEA
Thu Sep 19	@ STL	@ SEA
Fri Sep 20	@ CIN	@ OAK
Sat Sep 21	@ CIN	@ OAK
Sun Sep 22	@ CIN	@ OAK
Tue Sep 24	vs. MIL	vs. BAL
Wed Sep 25	vs. MIL	vs. BAL
Thu Sep 26	vs. MIL	vs. BAL
Fri Sep 27	@ NYY	vs. PIT
Sat Sep 28	@ NYY	vs. PIT
Sun Sep 29	@ NYY	vs. PIT

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension